Get a Free Quote

Article

Liquid BBL vs Surgical BBL: Results, Risks and How Long Each Lasts

Dr. Arda Akgun, Plastic, reconstructive and aesthetic surgery
Medically reviewed by Dr. Arda Akgun Plastic, reconstructive and aesthetic surgery Reviewed

An independent partner surgeon checked the medical claims on this page. What applies to your own case is decided by the surgeon who examines you.

Written by the editorial team, not by a clinician. Nothing here is medical advice: your independent partner surgeon decides what applies to you.

Woman in black sportswear standing side-on against a white wall, looking back over her shoulder

A liquid BBL shapes the buttocks with injected filler instead of your own fat. Because it needs no liposuction or general anaesthetic, it is often sold as a quick, non-surgical BBL. The evidence is more cautious: filler gives a smaller change, most of it is absorbed within about two years, and UK surgical bodies treat buttock filler as a surgical procedure (1, 2, 3).

A surgical BBL moves fat from areas such as the stomach or flanks into the buttocks. It is a bigger operation with a longer recovery, but on average most of the transferred fat stays, and its most serious risk has fallen since surgeons changed where they place the fat (4, 5). This guide compares a liquid BBL vs a surgical BBL on results, risks and how long each lasts.

Liquid BBLSurgical BBL
What is injectedFiller, usually hyaluronic acid; sometimes Sculptra (6, 7)Your own fat, taken by liposuction (4)
Typical amountAbout 340 mL in total in the main study (1)About 400 mL into each side on average (8)
SessionsHyaluronic acid adds volume at once; Sculptra needs several sessions (7)One operation
How long it lastsMostly absorbed within about 2 years (2)On average 60% to 80% of the fat stays long term (4)
Main serious risksInfection, abscess, and filler blocking a blood vessel (9, 10)Fat embolism, now less common with fat placed above the muscle (5)
Approval and regulationNo filler is approved for the buttocks in the US; UK surgical bodies treat it as surgery (3, 10)An established operation with published safety recommendations (11)

What is a liquid BBL?

"Liquid BBL" is the popular name for buttock augmentation with dermal filler (9). A practitioner injects large volumes of filler, usually hyaluronic acid, into the buttocks to add volume or change their shape. Unlike a surgical BBL, no fat is removed or transferred.

The word "non-surgical" can be misleading. Guidance signed by UK surgical bodies, including the Royal College of Surgeons of England and BAAPS, says buttock augmentation with filler or fat "is considered to be a surgical procedure" and should be done only by suitably trained surgeons in CQC-registered premises (3). The UK advertising regulator has also upheld complaints against a liquid BBL advert that trivialised the risks (12).

What is injected in a liquid BBL?

Three types of filler are used, and they work differently:

  • Hyaluronic acid: a gel that adds volume straight away and is gradually absorbed. Most published buttock studies used this type (6).
  • Poly-L-lactic acid (Sculptra): adds little volume at first. It stimulates your own collagen over several sessions and months, so results build slowly (7, 13).
  • Calcium hydroxylapatite (Radiesse): we found no published studies of it for buttock enlargement, only small studies for loose skin and cellulite.

No filler is approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for the buttocks. The FDA recommends against using fillers to increase the size of the buttocks, and approved uses are limited to areas such as the face and the back of the hands (10). Using Sculptra or Radiesse in the buttocks is therefore off-label.

Fillers that should never be injected

Some providers offer a "permanent" liquid BBL. These products are not approved for the buttocks, and they cannot be dissolved:

  • Liquid silicone: the FDA says injectable silicone is not approved for any cosmetic use, including body contouring (10). Silicone can travel through the bloodstream to the lungs, which is a life-threatening emergency (14, 15).
  • Hydrogels (such as polyamide and polyacrylamide gels): France's medicines regulator announced the withdrawal of the Los Deline body filler from the market in 2023 and warned that hard lumps (granulomas) can appear 2 to 10 years after injection (16). One clinical team has reported surgically removing another hydrogel, Aquafilling, from 146 patients with complications (17).
  • PMMA: permanent fillers of this kind are approved in the US only for smile lines and acne scars on the cheeks (10).

The FDA's advice is clear: never have any permanent filler or liquid silicone injected to shape the body (18). If a provider offers a permanent liquid BBL, walk away.

How much change can a liquid BBL give?

A liquid BBL adds less volume than a surgical BBL. In the main hyaluronic acid study, 61 patients received an average of 340 mL of filler in total, between 200 and 420 mL (1). Surgical BBL studies report an average of about 400 mL of fat injected into each side (8), although part of that fat is reabsorbed in the first months (4).

Sculptra works more gradually. In a trial of 30 women, patients had 3 sessions about a month apart, and 84% were rated as improved 6 months after the last session (7). Another study found that visible results needed 20 or more vials in total (13). These studies measured better contour and skin quality rather than a large increase in size.

How long does a liquid BBL last?

Hyaluronic acid filler is absorbed gradually. One study used MRI scans to measure how much gel remained, and a larger study asked patients whether they still saw an improvement (1, 2):

Time after treatmentGel remaining on MRIPatients who still saw an improvement
6 months56%80%
12 months36%68%
18 monthsNot measured42%
24 months24%40%

A review of hyaluronic acid buttock studies put the average effect at about 16 months (6). Only a third of patients in the main study were satisfied at 2 years (1), so keeping the shape means repeat treatments.

For Sculptra in the buttocks, follow-up reaches about 2 years in a single study (13), so how long it lasts there is still unclear.

With a surgical BBL, part of the fat is reabsorbed in the first months. On average, patients keep 60% to 80% of the transferred fat, and the final result shows at about one year (4). One study measured an average of 66% at about six months (19). The fat that survives behaves like the rest of your body fat, so it can shrink or grow if your weight changes (4). Our BBL recovery guide explains what happens in the first weeks and months.

Liquid BBL risks

Most reported side effects are short-term, such as bruising, redness and swelling. Fluid collecting around the filler and filler moving away from where it was injected have also been reported (6).

Serious complications are less common but well documented:

  • Infection, abscess and sepsis: BAAPS reports patients of unqualified providers developing sepsis, tissue loss and scarring (9).
  • Blocked blood vessels: filler injected into a blood vessel can cut off the blood supply to the skin and cause tissue loss (10).
  • Embolism: BAAPS warns that filler and fat methods share the risks of embolism and severe bleeding (20). Two studies in a review of hyaluronic acid buttock injections reported serious bleeding in the lungs (6).

Nobody knows how often these complications happen, because there is no register of liquid BBL treatments. The best UK picture comes from Save Face, a register of practitioners accredited by the Professional Standards Authority (21). It has collected 1,138 complaints about non-surgical BBLs and breast augmentation since 2023 and reports that more than half involved severe complications such as infection, sepsis or abscess, that 96% of patients needed NHS treatment, and that in every case the person injecting had no healthcare qualification (22). These are patient reports rather than a study, but they suggest that who injects matters a great deal.

Surgical BBL risks and what has changed

In a surgical BBL, fat is removed by liposuction, prepared and injected into the buttocks. Its most serious risk is fat embolism: if fat is injected into or under the buttock muscle, it can enter large veins and travel to the lungs, which is life-threatening (23).

That risk has fallen since surgeons changed technique. In 2017, a task force of US surgeons estimated the risk of the most serious outcome at about 1 in 3,448 operations a year, with estimates ranging from 1 in 2,351 to 1 in 6,214 (23). After safety guidance told surgeons to place fat only above the muscle, a 2019 survey put it at about 1 in 14,952, and the share of surgeons injecting into the muscle fell from 13.1% to 0.8% (5).

Where the surgery happens also matters. A review of the most serious fat embolism cases in South Florida between 2010 and 2022 found that 92% of the patients had surgery at high-volume, low-cost clinics (24).

BAAPS now recommends that surgeons (11):

  • inject fat only into the layer under the skin, never into the muscle
  • use ultrasound during surgery to check where the cannula is
  • use cannulas of at least 4 mm
  • perform no more than 3 BBLs a day
  • take consent themselves and allow at least 2 weeks between consultation and surgery

Ultrasound makes sense in principle, but a 2026 review found that the evidence for it is still limited and mostly comes from studies without a comparison group (25).

Other complications are mostly minor. A review of 19 studies and 4,105 patients found complications in about 7%, with major complications in 0.32% (8). The most common include fluid build-up (seroma), infection and sciatic nerve pain (26). Our Brazilian butt lift page explains the operation in more detail.

Who suits which?

No study has compared a liquid BBL with a surgical BBL directly, so the choice depends on what you want and on your body.

  • You want a noticeable change that lasts: a surgical BBL is the option with long-term evidence, because part of the transferred fat stays permanently (4). It also slims the areas the fat is taken from.
  • You have very little fat to spare: a surgical BBL may not be possible. Buttock implants, sometimes combined with a small fat transfer, are the main surgical alternative (27). Implants carry their own risks, with complications in about 1 in 5 patients in one review, mainly wound problems (26).
  • You want a small, temporary change: filler can add some shape, but expect it to fade within about two years and plan for top-ups (1). In the UK, it should be done only by a suitably qualified doctor in CQC-registered premises (3).
  • Your weight is still changing: wait until it is stable. Transferred fat grows and shrinks with your weight (4).

United States: no filler is approved for the buttocks, and the FDA recommends against using fillers or silicone to enlarge them (10, 14).

England: there are currently few restrictions on who can perform cosmetic procedures. In October 2026 the government proposed that filler injected anywhere other than the face be treated as surgery. Liquid BBLs would be limited to GMC-registered doctors working for CQC-registered providers, with unlimited fines for breaking the rules. The consultation closes on 13 January 2027, and the plan is not yet law (28).

Scotland: the Scottish Government plans to limit fillers used to reshape the body, including for BBLs, to healthcare professionals working in settings regulated by Healthcare Improvement Scotland (29).

Questions to ask before anyone injects

If you are considering a liquid BBL, ask:

  • Is the person injecting a GMC-registered doctor, and are the premises registered with the CQC (or Healthcare Improvement Scotland)? (3)
  • Are they on a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority? (21)
  • Which product will be used, and where does it come from? (21)
  • Will I get a written record of the product, the injection sites and the volumes? (16)
  • Is hyaluronidase, the enzyme that dissolves hyaluronic acid, kept on site with other emergency medicines? (3)
  • Can I have a consultation before I pay? (21)

Be wary of anyone who advertises only on social media, has trained only on a short course, or offers treatment in a home or hotel room (21).

If you are considering a surgical BBL, ask your surgeon (11):

  • Will the fat be placed only under the skin, above the muscle?
  • Will you use ultrasound during the operation?
  • How many BBLs do you perform in a day?
  • Will I meet you before the day of surgery, and how much time will I have to decide?

Warning signs after a liquid BBL

Call 999 in the UK or 911 in the US if you have (30, 31):

  • sudden shortness of breath or chest pain
  • coughing up blood
  • confusion, slurred speech or not making sense
  • blue, grey, pale or blotchy skin, lips or tongue

Contact the person who treated you, or call NHS 111, if the treated area becomes increasingly painful, hot, red or swollen, leaks fluid, or the skin over it changes colour, or if you have a fever or feel generally unwell (9, 10).

Frequently asked questions

Does a liquid BBL actually work?

It adds some shape and volume, but less than fat transfer. In the main hyaluronic acid study, 80% of patients saw an improvement at 6 months and 40% at 2 years (1).

How long does a liquid BBL last?

Hyaluronic acid is absorbed gradually: in one MRI study, about a quarter of the gel remained after 2 years (2). Evidence on how long Sculptra lasts in the buttocks is limited (13).

Is a liquid BBL the same as Sculptra?

Not exactly. Liquid BBL describes any buttock filler. Sculptra is one product used for it, off-label; it stimulates collagen gradually rather than filling straight away (7, 10).

Is there a permanent liquid BBL?

Not a safe one. Permanent fillers such as liquid silicone, hydrogels and PMMA are not approved for the buttocks, cannot be dissolved, and can cause hard lumps and infection years later (10, 16).

Which is better, a BBL or a liquid BBL?

For a noticeable, lasting change, a surgical BBL usually achieves more if you have enough fat, because part of the fat stays permanently (4). Filler gives a smaller, temporary change. No study compares them directly.

Is a liquid BBL safer than a surgical BBL?

No study has compared them. The main surgical risk, fat embolism, has fallen since fat is placed above the muscle (5). Liquid BBL has no reliable complication figures, and UK surgical bodies class it as surgery (3).

Can a liquid BBL be dissolved?

Only hyaluronic acid filler can be dissolved, with an enzyme called hyaluronidase, which is used off-label for this (3, 32). Sculptra, Radiesse and permanent fillers cannot be dissolved.

Is a liquid BBL legal in the UK?

For adults, yes for now. England plans to treat it as cosmetic surgery, limited to GMC-registered doctors in CQC-registered clinics; the consultation closes on 13 January 2027 (28). Scotland plans similar limits (29).

Next steps

Before choosing, decide how much change you want and how long you want it to last, then have both options explained by a surgeon who has examined you. A surgeon can tell you whether you have enough fat for a BBL and what result is realistic for your body. Istanbul European Clinic does not arrange liquid BBLs. Istanbul European Clinic does not provide surgery; every clinical decision is made by your independent partner surgeon.

Thinking about a surgical BBL?

Tell us what you would like to change, and a coordinator will explain how an assessment with a partner surgeon works and what to ask.

Talk to a coordinator

Sources

  1. De Meyere B, Mir-Mir S, Peñas J, Camenisch CC, Hedén P. Stabilized Hyaluronic Acid Gel for Volume Restoration and Contouring of the Buttocks: 24-Month Efficacy and Safety. Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2014;38(2):404-412.
  2. Camenisch CC, Tengvar M, Hedén P. Macrolane for volume restoration and contouring of the buttocks: magnetic resonance imaging study on localization and degradation. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2013;132(4):522e-529e.
  3. Joint Council for Cosmetic Practitioners (JCCP), Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (CIEH) and British Beauty Council. Buttock augmentation and other body contouring procedures: guidance for enforcement by local authority authorised officers. October 2024.
  4. American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Buttock augmentation: the procedure.
  5. Rios L Jr, Gupta V. Improvement in Brazilian Butt Lift (BBL) Safety With the Current Recommendations from ASERF, ASAPS, and ISAPS. Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 2020;40(8):864-870.
  6. Mortada H, Alkadi D, Saqr H, et al. Effectiveness and Role of Using Hyaluronic Acid Injections for Gluteal Augmentation: A Comprehensive Systematic Review of Techniques and Outcomes. Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2023;47(6):2719-2733.
  7. Nikolis A, Enright KM, Avelar LE, et al. A Prospective, Multicenter Trial on the Efficacy and Safety of Poly-L-Lactic Acid for the Treatment of Contour Deformities of the Buttock Regions. Journal of Drugs in Dermatology, 2022;21(3):295-304.
  8. Condé-Green A, Kotamarti V, Nini KT, et al. Fat Grafting for Gluteal Augmentation: A Systematic Review of the Literature and Meta-Analysis. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2016;138(3):437e-446e.
  9. British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (BAAPS). The BAAPS calls for urgent regulation of BBL procedures. 23 October 2024.
  10. US Food and Drug Administration. Dermal Fillers (Soft Tissue Fillers).
  11. Tillo O, Nassab R, Pacifico MD. The British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (BAAPS) Gluteal Fat Grafting Safety Review and Recommendations. Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 2023;43(6):675-682.
  12. Advertising Standards Authority. ASA Ruling on NKD Medical Ltd. 16 April 2025.
  13. Durairaj KK, Devgan L, Lee A, et al. Poly-L-Lactic Acid for Gluteal Augmentation found to be Safe and Effective in Retrospective Clinical Review of 60 Patients. Dermatologic Surgery, 2020;46(Suppl 1):S46-S53.
  14. US Food and Drug Administration. FDA warns about illegal use of injectable silicone for body contouring and associated health risks. 13 November 2017.
  15. Schmid A, et al. Silicone embolism syndrome: a case report, review of the literature, and comparison with fat embolism syndrome. Chest, 2005;127(6):2276-2281.
  16. Agence nationale de sécurité du médicament et des produits de santé (ANSM). Produits de comblement du volume de corps Los Deline: retrait du marché de l’ensemble des produits. 7 September 2023.
  17. Namgoong S, et al. Clinical Experience with Treatment of Aquafilling Filler-Associated Complications: A Retrospective Study of 146 Cases. Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2020;44(6):1997-2007.
  18. International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ISAPS). Patient safety statement: illegal injectable silicone for body contouring, reproducing the FDA Safety Communication of 1 February 2023.
  19. Swanson E. Prospective Controlled Study of Buttock Fat Transfer Using Ultrasound and Photographic Measurements. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Global Open, 2016;4(5):e697.
  20. British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (BAAPS). Addendum to BAAPS statement on BBL. 3 December 2025.
  21. NHS. Choosing who will do your cosmetic procedure.
  22. Save Face. Non-surgical BBL and breast augmentation complaints and complications report (patient-reported data).
  23. Mofid MM, Teitelbaum S, Suissa D, et al. Report on Mortality from Gluteal Fat Grafting: Recommendations from the ASERF Task Force. Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 2017;37(7):796-806.
  24. Pazmiño P, Garcia O. Brazilian Butt Lift-Associated Mortality: The South Florida Experience. Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 2023;43(2):162-178.
  25. Vázquez-Guerra XC, et al. Ultrasound in Gluteal Fat Grafting: Safety Tool, Standard of Care, or Emerging Evidence?: A Scoping Review. Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 2026.
  26. Sinno S, et al. Determining the Safety and Efficacy of Gluteal Augmentation: A Systematic Review of Outcomes and Complications. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2016;137(4):1151-1156.
  27. Cárdenas-Camarena L, Trujillo-Méndez R, Díaz-Barriga JC. Tridimensional Combined Gluteoplasty: Liposuction, Buttock Implants, and Fat Transfer. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2020;146(1):53-63.
  28. Department of Health and Social Care. Restrictions on the performance of high-risk cosmetic and wellbeing procedures in England: consultation document. 21 October 2026.
  29. Scottish Government. Regulation and licensing of non-surgical cosmetic procedures: consultation analysis and response. 25 June 2025.
  30. NHS. Pulmonary embolism.
  31. NHS. Sepsis.
  32. King M, Convery C, Davies E. The Use of Hyaluronidase in Aesthetic Practice (v2.4). Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology, 2018;11(6):E61-E68.

Related treatments

Get a Free Quote